Lindsay Ann Bakes: Faux "Soft Serve" Cone Meringue Cookies

Sunday, July 10, 2011

Faux "Soft Serve" Cone Meringue Cookies

Pin It

How great are these melt-free soft serve cones!? This might just be my favorite post from my collection of ice cream themed treats published all week for National Ice Cream Day. The trick to getting these cones not to melt is that they are not made out of ice cream at all! These mile high swirls of chocolate/vanilla soft serve are actually meringue cookies, piped to look just like real soft serve ice cream! 

I got the idea on my birthday a few weeks ago, when I treated myself to some frozen yogurt. So, I basically ended up drinking half of my soft serve because it was so hot out... leading me to my mission to create a melt free soft serve... and voila, faux soft serve ice cream cones made from meringue cookies (a low calorie, airy, melt in your mouth cookie, made of egg whites and sugar). The meringues take a while to dry, preferably overnight, so you can make the meringues the night before, and assemble when ready to serve.

Meringue Cookie "Soft Serve" Cones

Yields: 10-12 meringue cookie cones

You will need
  • 3 piping bags or ziplock baggies
  • 3 large egg whites (separate when cold and then bring to room temperature)
  • 1/4 teaspoon cream of tartar 
  • 1/4 teaspoon clear vanilla extract
  • 3/4 cup white granulated sugar
  • 2 tablespoons unsweetened cocoa powder
  • 10-12 ice cream cones
  • candy to fill your cones (jelly beans, M&M's, marshmallows, etc.) 


Preheat oven to 200 degrees F. Line a baking pan with parchment paper. Turn your cones upside down on parchment paper and trace 12 circles. This will be your size guide for piping the meringue "soft serve" swirls.

Separate eggs when cold, right out of the fridge, and let whites sit for about 30 min. to bring them to room temperature so they can puff up as much as possible. Make sure there is NO egg yolk in your egg whites and no grease or water on your beaters or in the bowl, none at all, or your egg whites will not whip up properly.  Here is my video: How To Separate Egg Yolks From Egg Whites (4 ways) to help you out.

Using the whisk attachment of your electric mixer (or with a hand mixer), beat room temperature egg whites on medium speed until frothy. 

Add the cream of tartar and vanilla and beat egg whites until they hold soft peaks. (when you lift the whisk, the tips will fall over). 

Very gradually add the sugar 1 tablespoon at a time and then increase the speed to medium-high and beat for about 7 minutes, until the meringue holds glossy, stiff peaks, and sugar has fully dissolved. You will know the meringue is ready when you lift the whisk and the tips stick straight up without drooping and when you rub meringue between your fingers it feels smooth and not gritty.

Place half of the meringue in a piping bag. Add cocoa powder to remaining half, and fold into meringue. Transfer into a separate piping bag.

Snip off the tip of the 2 bags, and place side by side in a third piping bag. Snip about 2" off the tip off of the third bag. 

Pipe up tall swirls of meringue on the parchment paper lined baking sheet, using the circles as your guide. Make sure you pipe the base of the meringues inside of your circle template, so they are not too wide, and rest on the top of the cone nicely when they expand during baking. 

Bake the meringues for about 1 hour and 45 minutes-2 hours. (The meringues are done when they are pale, crisp, and easily peel off the parchment paper.) Turn the oven heat off, leaving the meringues in the oven to finish drying for at least 4 hours or preferably overnight. Cover and store at room temperature for several days. 

To assemble, fill cones with candy or treats and place meringue cookies on top. If you want the meringue to stick to the cone, you can use melted white chocolate as a "glue" by dipping the top of the cone in chocolate and pressing meringues on top; let dry. The are great as a party favor, too!


Pin It


  1. Hi, found this post trough craftgossip today and it brought back my childhood memories. I'm from Poland but have been living in Sweden since 1984. When i was a kid i rememder eating faux soft serve cones in Poland, i'm not sure what they where made of (possibly meringues) and they where called hot cones. You could buy them everywhere, there was a kiosk just outside my house selling them.
    I must try making these some day. :)

  2. I also found about you through CraftGossip and sure glad that I did as those ice cream cones are adorable and Oh, so easy to make.
    Thank you
    I went to sign up to receive your monthly newsletter; filled in my email address but there is no 'submit' button.

  3. @Joanna, wow, that is so neat! Be sure to send me a photo if you make them, I would love to see how they turned out!

    @Colleen, Thanks, so glad you found us! Be sure to check us out on Facebook for the most up to date recipes and tutorials. To subscribe tour monthly newsletter, simply enter your email address and press Enter/Return to submit.

  4. OMG I can't believe that I found your blog just in time. I have been asked to make a cake that looks like soft serve ice cream in an upside down plastic batter's helmet. I have been losing sleep wondering how I was going to do a giant vanilla and chocolate swirl. Now I know. Thank you so much for this awesome idea!!

  5. I am so glad you found us in time! The faux soft serve meringue cookies in the plastic helmets sounds like such an adorable idea! Just like at a baseball game :) You'll have to email us a photo of post one on the DollhouseBakeShoppe Facebook page to let us know how they turn out, I would love to see them! Good luck!